FinancialCheckup101 · 100 questions
Which accounts should I draw from first: my taxable account, my IRA or my Roth?
By FinancialCheckup101 Research Staff · Last reviewed October 26, 2026
The conventional rule of thumb is to spend the taxable account first, then tax-deferred accounts such as a traditional IRA, and the tax-exempt Roth last. In "Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Strategies," Financial Analysts Journal 71, no. 2 (2015), Kirsten A. Cook, William Meyer and William Reichenstein describe that conventional sequence and show that more tax-efficient strategies can add more than three years to a portfolio's longevity compared with it. Their approach, as the published abstract summarizes it, times tax-deferred withdrawals and Roth conversions to use years when the tax rate is low.
The study is a model built on stated tax and return assumptions, so the size of any benefit depends on the household. Required minimum distributions, which begin at 73 for those born 1951 to 1959 and 75 for those born 1960 or later, limit how long IRA withdrawals can be deferred. Medicare premiums and the taxation of Social Security also respond to the income each withdrawal creates.
Authority: Cook, Meyer and Reichenstein, Financial Analysts Journal 71(2): 16 to 29 (2015); IRC 401(a)(9).
Sources: Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Strategies (CFA Institute Research and Policy Center); Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Strategies (IDEAS/RePEc); Required Minimum Distributions (T.D. 10001), Federal Register, July 19, 2024
From the list: 100 Questions Retirees Ask, Volume One
Free checkup: Approaching Retirement